CPRAR 05-04-07, Provide Documents Indicating All Active Litigation, Addendum 1

<\NGUARD

Page 1 of 2

/ Varpetian, Lucy

From:

Varpetian, Lucy

Sent:

Monday, May 14, 2007 5:02 PM

To:	'ba@fieldworks.net'

Cc:	Kassakhian, Ardashes; Buchanan, Rita

Subject: RE: CPRAR 50407 Act Lit

Mr. Allen:

Records responsive to your request will be available for inspection in the office of the City Clerk on Wednesday, May 16, 2007, after 3:00 p.m.

$2ucp Q? arpetitll1

Senior Assistant City Attorney Office of the Glendale City Attorney 613 East Broadway, Suite 220 Glendale, CA 91206

Tel: 818-548-2080

Fax: 818-547-3402

-----Original Message-----

From: Barry [mailto:ba@fieldworks.net] Sent: Friday, May 04,200712:12 PM

To: Kassakhian, Ardashes; Varpetian, Lucy; Buchanan, Rita Subject: CPRAR 50407 Act Lit

VANGUARD

POB 11202, Glendale, CA 91226 8182431502 - vanguard1 @charter.net Contributions are tax deductible - Rev. Proc. 92-85, 1992-421.R.B. 32 VIGILANCE leads to ACCOUNTABILITY

Ardy Kassakhian, City Clerk City of Glendale, CA

613 E. Broadway

Glendale, CA 91206

RE: Public Records Act Request Reference: _50407 Active Lit

Dear Mr. Kassakhian:

Pursuant to my rights under the California Public Records Act (Government Code Section 6250 et seq.) and the California Constitution, as amended by passage of Prop 59 on November 3,2004, I am writing to request inspection of the following records, which I understand to be in the possession of your agency:

Documents indicating all active litigation.

I ask for a determination on this request within 10 days of your receipt of it, and an even earlier reply if

5/16/2007

VANGBARD

Page 2 of 2

you can make that determination without having to review the record(s) in question.

If you determine that any or all or the information is exempt from disclosure, I ask that you reconsider that determination in view of Prop 59, which has amended the state Constitution to require that all exemptions be "narrowly construed." Prop 59 may modify or overturn authorities on which you have relied in the past.

If you nonetheless determine that the requested records are subject to a still-valid exemption, I would further request that: (1) you exercise your discretion to disclose some or all of the records notwithstanding the exemption; and (2) that, with respect to records containing both exempt and non-exempt content, you redact the exempt content and disclose the rest.

You must provide assistance by helping to identify records and information relevant to the request and suggesting ways to overcome any practical basis for denying access.

Finally, should you deny part or this entire request, you are required to provide a written response describing the legal authority or authorities on which you rely. Please also address the question whether Prop 59 requires disclosure even though authorities predating Prop 59 may appear to support your exemption claim.

Records concerning litigation are exempt only until the claim is resolved or settled. Upon disposition all records including court records and those pre-dating the suit are public.

If I can provide any clarification that will help expedite your attention to this request, please contact me at the number above. I ask that you notify me of any duplication costs so that I may decide which records I want copied.

I am sending a copy of this letter to your legal advisor to help encourage a speedy determination, and I would likewise be happy to discuss my request with him or his designee at any time.

Thank you for your time and attention to this matter.

Barry Allen

5/16/2007

PENDING LAWSUITS

PLAINTIFF

DEFENDANT

EC043267

ALTADONNA, MOLLY; ALTADONNA, FRANK

NATIONAL READY MIXED CONCRETE COMPANY; PEREZ, JOEL G., AN INDIVIDUAL;

SIALIC CONTRACTORS, DBA SHAWNAN; CITY OF GLENDALE;

DOES 1 - 50

BAGHDANIAN, AVYDIS BAGHDANIAN, ARIKNAZ

COG;

JAMES E. STARBIRD; STEPHEN M. ZURN ; DOES 1-25

BALAIAN,OVANES

CITY OF GLENDALE, CALIFORNIA; DOES 1-10

BEDIKIAN, ARPINEE BEDIKIAN, VAROUJAN

COG,

EPAC DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, EPAC GLENDALE PARTNERS, LLC., GEOSOILS CONSULTANTS, INC., DOES 1 - 100

BERKE, KATHLEEN ELlANE

COG; JESUS PASTEN, ET AL.

BOULWARE, F. KEELIN

COG;

GLENDALE POLICE DEPARTMENT; WILLIAMS, RANDY, CHIEF OF GPD; DOES 1-50

CASE NO.

EC044284

07C02373

BC340013

EC036344

EC043838

PLAIN:rIFF

DEFENDANT

CASE NO.

CAJERO, GUADALUPE

CITY OF SANTA MONICA CITY OF GLENDALE

SC088730

COMITE DE JORNALEROS DE GLENDALE NATIONAL LABORER ORGANIZING NETWORK

COG

CV04-3521 SJO(EX)

CONNECT TO COMMUNICATIONS, INC.

COG

DOES 1-100

EC042453

COSTNER,CHERYLYNN; COSTNER, GARY STEVEN; BROWN, HEWLETTE ROGERS, CORNELL, RETIRED LUITENENT

CLINTON, VESTA ANN, ET AL.

CV06-5481

COVARRUBIAS, JOSE MIGUEL

GLENDALE GALLERIA CITY OF GLENDALE DOES 1 TO 10

BC364552

FEELEY, THOMAS J.; FEELEY, WAL TRAUD

COG; DOES 1-10

EC042133

FENTON, ROBERT, DOING BUSINESS AS FENTON & FENTON

COG; GRA, A BODY POLITIC, DOES 1 TO 20

LC043853

PLAINTIFF

DEFENDANT

CASE NO.

FULLERTON, THOMAS; FULLERTON, LINDA

COG; DOES 1-10

BC339640

GANGI, MARK GANGI, JEANNE

COG DOES 1-10

BC339664

GARCEAU, RUSSELL; DENISE GARCEAU; DONALD ROSS; JANE ROSS; M&R MACHINE, INC.

CITY OF GLENDALE WATER & POWER

BC278909

GEYER, RUSSELL

COG DOES 1-30

EC043085

GOGAN, SUZAN

WILSON, DAVID ALLEN COG

DOES 1-20

EC043056

HARMON, DEVIN

MARTIN MARSHALL MIGUEL PORRAS RANDY ADAMS

CV 07 -398-FMC(AJ\II

HEAPHY, JOHN AND ELEANOR

COG;

DOES 1 TO 75

EC042029

PLAINTIFF

HERNANDEZ, MARIA;

SANDIL, SHERYL, A MINOR, BY ROXANA HERNANDEZ, HER PARENT AND GUARDIAN AD LITEM

HILL, JOHN & CYNDY

HOYT, ROBERT; HOYT, MICHAEL

KEYVANIAN, GEORGE

KHACHATURYAN, SEDA, BY AND THROUGH HER GUARDIAN AD LITEM, KHACHATURYAN, MARINA

KHAN,ASRAR

KNOX, IVERIA, MOTHER OF CLIFTON HUTCHINS

DEFENDANT

MELONAKOS, KANDICE MARIE; CANAS, JOAQUIN;

CITY OF GLENDALE;

MV TRANSPORTATION, INC.

COG;

GREGORY POWERS; AILEEN AZADIAN; SCOTT HOWARD; JAMES STARBIRD; RAFI MANOUKIAN; DAVID WEAVER; ROBERT YOUSEFIAN;

JERRY UEBEL; MARK HANSON; ALEX MINJARES; LUCIEN LEBLANC; JAN BEAR;

DOES 1-50

STATE OF CALIFORNIA; CITY OF GLENDALE;

GLENDALE POLICE DEPARTMENT; MONTECUOLLO, GARY;

TWEDT, DORIS;

DOES 1-100

COG

DOES 1 - 10

COG

DOES 1 - 25

RJ DEVELOPMENT, INC. BIZAR, RICHARD DAVID

AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INDEMNITY CO. COG

DOES 1-100

ROSENBLATT, MICHELE; ADOMIAN, NATALIA; FRANK, ARTHUR;

RILEY, TORI; LIGHTFOOT, TOWNY

CASE NO.

EC043730

EC039332

EC043824

BC339643

EC044292

EC042387

CV06-05625

PLAINTIFF

DEFENDANT

KOON, MARCIE

COG;

DOMINGUEZ, CARLOS; DOES 1-20

LARRIGAN, PATRICIA

COG

MA'AT-RA, DJEHUTY

BEN BATEMAN; XZAVIAATKINS; ROBERT MORRIS

MALYAN, RUBEN

COG;

BRANCH, EDWARD KEVIN; DOES 1-20

MARKARIAN, BEATRICE

COG; DOES 1-20

MARTINEZ, HELEN

CITY OF GLENDALE;

GRAY, CHRISTOPHER ROBERT; HOWELL, LUCAS ROBERT; DOES 1 TO 20

MCTAGUE, LOUIS F.;

MCTAGUE, LOUIS F. AS TRUSTEE OF THE LOUIS F. MCTAGUE LIVING TRUST

CITY OF GLENDALE;

EPAC DEVELOPMENT COMPANY;

CASE NO.

EC043152

EC038890

CV032508R(AN)

EC044501

EC044074

BC360587

BC339015

PLAINTIFF

DEFENDANT

MOLANO, HERBERT

COG;

WEAVER, DAVID; DOES 1-25

MOLANO, HERBERT; SMOLlNISKY, ALAN;

CONQUEST STUDENT HOUSING, LLC

COG; DOES 1-50

MORENO, ANGELA

COG

PHILIP LANZAFAME JEANNIE ARMSTRONG

MUHAMMAD, RAHEEM

VARGAS, RAYMOND BLAKE; MADAL Y AN SIEGLER, CAROLINA

HOUSING AUTHORITY OF CITY OF GLENDALE COG

NASELLA, NICHOLAS J.

COG; GPD;

ADAMS, RANDY; CHIEF OF GPD; TSURUTA, YORK; OFFICER RILEY;

FORMER OFFICER D. KWANT

NAVARRO, L1LLlBETH, AN INDIVIDUAL

COG;

ALEX REGIONAL THEATRE BOARD; SMITH, KAREN;

DOES 1-100

NGO, PHONG

CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION; COG;

DOES 1-10

WATER SERVICES ADM. OF COG (REAL PARTY IN INTEREST)

CASE NO.

EC044104

BS106394

BC364230

BS092216

CV-05-07191 CJC (J.

EC042925

BS108150

PLAINTIFF

DEFENDANT

O'NEAL, PATRICK

FINERTY, CAROL D. COG

OJEDA,ALBERTO

COG;

ANDREA SERAFIN; DOES 1 TO 100

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY; SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY;

CALIFORNIA ELECTRICITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

ARIZONA ELECTRIC POWER COOPERATIVE, INC.; CITY OF ANAHEIM;

CITY OF AZUSA;

CITY OF BANNING;

CITY OF BURBANK;

COG;

CITY OF LOS ANGELES; CITY OF PASADENA; CITY OF RIVERSIDE;

ARIZONA ELECTRIC POWER COOPERATIVE, INC. CITY OF ANAHEIM;

CITY OF AZUSA;

CITY OF BANNING;

CITY OF BURBANK;

CITY OF GLENDALE;

CITY OF LOS ANGELES;

CITY OF PASADENT;

CITY OF RIVERSIDE;

COG;

THE GLENDALE CITY COUNCIL; YOUSEFIAN, BOB;

MANOUKIAN, RAFI;

NAJARIAN, ARA;

WEAVER, DAVE;

QUINTERO, FRANK;

FUENTES, EDITH M.;

GLENDALE ZONING ADMINISTRATOR;

COG;

OFCR JOHN DOE WILLIAMS; OFFICER JOHN DOE BOWMAN; DOES 1-10

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY; SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY;

SAN DIEGO GAG & ELECTRIC COMPANY; CALIFORNIA ELECTRICITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

PALM DRIVE HOLDINGS LTD. L.P., A CALIFORNIA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP

PASHAYI-MARANDI, All

PATSAOURAS & ASSOCIATES, INC.

DAN DWORSKY, STEVE RUEF, DWORSKY ASSOCIATES, INC., CITY OF GLENDALE, LARRY ZARIAN, EILEEN GIVENS, GINGER BREMBERG, DAVE WEAVER, SHELDON BAKER, J STARBIRD AND DOES 1-100

CASE NO.

EC044553

EC041240

2:06-CV-00559

BC369141

BS107547

CV05-7072 PJW

BC231143

PLAINTIFF

PIGGUE, MANUEL

POGOSYAN, ALINA

PORTLAND GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, AN OREGON CORPORATION

REYES, RICARDO RIVERA

SAHAKIAN, MICHAEL; SAHAKIAN, NATHALIE; SAVADIAN, KARINEH

SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY

SARKIS, SUE

DEFENDANT

GPD;

MENDOZA, MARK; CHACON, ANTHONY; ADAMS, RANDY

COG DOES 1-10

COG

COG; GPD;

COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES;

LOS ANGELES SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT; CITY OF MADERA;

M. GONZALEZ

COG;

OFFICER RUSSELL HANCOCK; OFFICER JASON ROSS; OFFICER FRANK MARTINEZ; HOLMES, WARREN

ARIZONA ELECTRIC POWER COOPERATIVE, INC.; CITY OF ANAHEIM, CALIFORNIA;

CITY OF AZUSA, CALIFORNIA;

CITY OF BANNING, CALIFORNIA;

CITY OF BURBANK, CALIFORNIA;

CITY OF GLENDALE, CALIFORNIA;

CITY OF LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA;

LOS ANGELES DWP;

CITY OF PASADENA, CALIFORNIA;

COG;

DOES 1-100

CASE NO.

CV05 0732 JFW (SS

06C03756

051321 BR

CV05 0253 GPS (MJI

CV05-7419 AHM (CV

2:06-CV-00592-WBS

EC042446

PLAINTIFF

SEQUOIA INSURANCE COMPANY AS SUBROGEE OF CONNECT TO COMMUNICATIONS

SHALCHIAN, EMMA

SHEKERDEMIAN, YEGHIA

SILVA, DOMINGO HERNANDEZ;

VITDALES, YOVANI, A MINOR BY AND THROUGH GUARDIAN AD LITEM, DOMINGO HERNANDEZ SILVA

SPRINGBORN, EUGENE; SPRINGBORN, JUDITH

TAFOYA,PAUL

TARVERDIAN, L1NA

DEFENDANT

CASE NO.

COG; DOES 1-20

EC044112

BORIS, PILAR; COG;

DOES 1-20

EC044543

COG; GPO;

DOES 1-100

EC041822

COG;

JIMENEZ, RUBEN JOE

05C04127

COG

BC338965

COG; GPO;

ANNIS, KENNY; MAZADIEGO, LOUIS; MARASCO, STEVE; DOES 1-10

EC041540

COG

EC041643

-PLAINTIFF

DEFENDANT

CASE NO.

TAYLOR, JASON

GPO; COG;

POLICE CHIEF RANDY ADAMS; FRAN JUDGE; M. BOLTON

CV-03-4870-(FMO)

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA EX REL, BILL LOCKYER, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, AND THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES

CITY OF GLENDALE

06AS02502

THE RESERVE GLENDALE I COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION

COG;

EPAC DEVELOPMENT COMPANY; EPAC GLENDALE PARTNERS, LLC; CW. POSS, INC.

DOES 1 THROUGH 100,

BC336611

TOLLACK, MICHAEL

COG;

DOES 1-100

BC363505

TRINIDAD, CESAR TRINIDAD, DIANE LANE

TRINIDAD, LAURELANN, A MINOR BY CESAR TRINIDAD

HAMEL, ANN K.

COG, ET AL.

BC 339 644

VARTANIANS, VARTAN

COG;

DOES 1 THROUGH 50

EC041940

VOSKANIAN, SHAHEN

GLENDALE ADVENTIST MEDICAL CENTER; CITY OF GLENDALE;

DOES 1-100

EC043172